Consulting pricing models: hourly, day rate, fixed fee, retainer or value-based
Short answer
Choose the model by how clear the scope and the value are. Unclear scope: hourly or a day rate. A clear deliverable: a fixed fee. Ongoing access: a retainer. A result you can put a number on: value-based. Whatever you choose, work out your hourly floor first, then offer three packages.
The five models, and when each fits
| When it fits | Model | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| The scope is genuinely unknown: discovery, troubleshooting, embedded help | Hourly | Caps your income: the faster you get, the less you earn |
| Workshops, strategy sprints, interim roles | Day rate | Still time-based; agree in writing what a “day” means |
| A clear deliverable with clear boundaries | Fixed fee per project | Scope creep, so you need a change-request clause |
| The client wants ongoing access to you | Monthly retainer | Set hours or response times, or it turns into “unlimited” |
| You and the client can put a number on the result | Value-based | Needs a good discovery call and numbers the client agrees with |
Set your price in 5 steps
- Work out your floor: (target income + yearly business costs) ÷ realistic billable hours. Example: ($200,000 + $20,000) ÷ 1,000 hours = $220 an hour. Price 20–30% above it.
- Measure your billable hours, don’t guess. The example assumes about half of a 48-week, 40-hour year is billable. Track every hour for 4 weeks in Toggl Track or Clockify (both have free plans) and use your own number.
- Choose a model per offer, not for your whole business, using the table above.
- Build three packages: a small paid diagnostic, a core project and an ongoing retainer. Each one lists deliverables, a timeline and what is not included.
- Send it with milestones: a proposal and contract with a deposit at signing and invoices by milestone, for example in Bonsai (Essentials, $19/user/mo billed yearly, includes proposals, contracts and invoices).
The value-based conversation
- Put a number on the problem: “What does this cost you each month today?” Write down their number, not yours.
- Put a number on the outcome: “If this is solved, what changes in revenue, cost or risk?”
- Price at a share of that value and show the two side by side, for example a $40,000 fee against a problem worth $400,000 a year.
- Offer the three packages, so the client decides which option, not whether to work with you.
It doesn’t work when the client can’t or won’t share numbers, or when the result depends mostly on things you don’t control. Use a fixed fee then.
Moving off hourly without a cash gap
- Start with new clients; finish current projects on the old terms.
- Ask for a deposit at signing and bill by milestone, so a fixed fee doesn’t mean waiting months for cash.
- Raise rates with 60–90 days’ notice, as your new standard rate from a set date.
Keep a fixed fee fixed
- List what is not included next to what is.
- Add a change-request clause: every addition gets a written estimate and approval before work starts.
- Use milestones as checkpoints: the next phase starts after the client accepts the last one.
The full process, with clauses you can copy, is in how to prevent scope creep.
Tools in this guide
- Bonsai
Proposals, contracts, deposits and milestone or recurring invoices.
- Toggl Track
Time tracking to find your real billable hours.
Consultants:Claire Holland (Uses it), Sarah Macklin (Uses it), Sarah Haler (Uses it)
- Clockify
A free time tracker if you only need the basics.
Consultants:Pawel Tatarek (Uses it)
- HubSpot CRM
Log deal values and results to back up value-based quotes.
Consultants:Pawel Tatarek (Uses it), Dvir Naaman (Recommends it), Amir Baldiga (Recommends it), Onkar Vengurlekar (Uses it)
See it as a stack
Get-paid stackProposal, time, invoice and books, without paying twice for the same job.See the stackQuestions
- Should I show my hourly rate on a fixed-fee proposal?
- No. Show the deliverables, the timeline and the price. Your hourly floor is for you, to check that the fee covers your time.
- Is value-based pricing only for big projects?
- It works best when the client can put a number on the result. For small or unclear work, a fixed fee or a short paid diagnostic is simpler.
- Retainer or project work for steady income?
- A retainer gives more predictable monthly income, but only with clear limits on hours or response times. Many consultants start with a project and offer a retainer after it.